Interesting income tax avoidance scheme



I'm currently looking at doing some (IT) contracting and some guy just
called me (got details from a recruitment agent) and spoke of a scheme
provided by the company he works for that means contractors can take
home much more of their hard-earned. He stressed the scheme was IR35
compliant. Blah blah.

Now my wife actually is a chartered acountant (though these days
working in property tax) and as she actually *is* a contractor I called
her and mentioned this scheme to her. She was dubious, but said she
might contact the guy to talk more about it.

I thought I'd ask here, to see if anyone knowledgeable thinks this
looks possible (legal) because the figures he gave me looked too good
to be true.

He said based on a notional contractor salary of £90k a year (we just
used that figure as an example), I'd take home £71k. He said (and
you'll excuse my lack of correct terms) what happens is this: you get
paid (by this company) 15% of your earnings as a proper salary, paying
income tax and NI. So in this case, you get paid 13500k a year (less
tax), so about £900 month. The rest is paid into a Trust in the Isle
of Mann and you get paid from this every 6 weeks. But he said as it's a
Trust, you're not subject to IR35 (because no shares/dividends) and I
think he said it (the payment) is treated as a Benefit In Kind
instead....whatver, but he said;

"we would propose a structure based on you remunerating yourself 15%
of your income via PAYE and the balance would be payable via a
structure that attracts tax at a rate of no more than 1.2%." this does sound too good to be true. I just wanted to know if
anyone skilled in this area thought it likely that such a scheme was
possible? He said the company worked mainly in the area of doing tax
scheme for High Net Worth individuals. *shrug*.

Just interested. Thanks for any comments offered.




sylvian stone

Some of these Isle of Man schemes do work - but they generally have a
limited shelf life. Currently, these schemes have to be registered with
the Revenue, who generally ammend the legislation at the first

Usually, if a few people are benefiting from these loopholes, they can
carry on for a while. But if lots of people are benefitting, you can
bet they will be blocked in the near future - at which point the tax
gurus will release a modified version of the same arrangement.

These can operate because there is a double tax treaty between the Isle
of Man and the UK. Therefore, if you have already been taxed in the
Isle of Man, you can't be taxed again in the UK - even if the IOM rates
are minimal.

I think I know what this scheme is, and who is running it, and to my
knowledge, it is working well for a lot of IT contractors.

The tax specialists will argue that if the Revenue and politicians
cannot word the legislation correctly, then why should they not take
advantage of it ?

On the other hand, you have to remember that this is aggressive tax
planning, and do not be surprised if the Revenue challenged you in the


Thanks for that Sylvian.

With reference to "do not be surprised if the Revenue challenged you in
future...... " are you referring simply to the Revenue closing such
"loopholes" in future? Or are you saying that the Revenue might seek to
employ some kind of retrospective legislation Re the 'earnings' I had
made under such an arrangement?

I'd been led to believe "retrospective legislation" was not likely (in
fact impossible) because EU law had decreed it so (after some test case
involving the Revenue)?



sylvian stone

The Revenue could do either, but in most cases it is likely to be the
first option . i.e. they make the arrangement ineffective with
immediate effect, and then you are in the position of paying the normal
amount of tax, or finding another arrangement.

They rarely impose retrospective legislation, but have done so recently
for certain types of trust which people have been using solely to avoid
Inheritance Tax liabilities. Whether this will be challenged and
overturned in the courts remain to be seen.

Generally, if you use one of the reputable Isle of Man Tax & Trust
companies, they will have got a QC's opinion on their scheme, and would
defend it through the courts if the Revenue came and challenged your
tax returns. That is how seriously they take these matters.

However, if you are the unlucky person who the Revenue challenged, it
would still cause you a lot of aggro, even if the Trust company paid
the barristers costs, etc.... But saying that, in the recent past,
when the Revenue have made tax demands on certain contractors, they
have been overturned or thrown out in the courts. It is at that point
when the Revenue turn to 'statutory instruments' to make these schemes
unworkable within immediate effect.

Anybody who knows about the 'Gilt Strip' schemes will know what I am
talking about....

As long as you are aware that this could happen, then I can't see any
reason why you can't use these schemes. They are perfectly legal.




sylvian said:
Some of these Isle of Man schemes do work
Thinking back to Geoffrey Robinson et al I thought one of the key points
was that you didn't have control over the trust, which does not seem to
be the case here. I would also be worried about about the company
running the trust going bust.

I thought IR35 was pretty much an optional tax anyway? I don't know any
of my contractor friends who are paying it.

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question